Jason Voorhees Vs Roy Burns

1. This debate is strictly Human Jason from Part 2 through Part 4!

2. Debate with facts if you are making a serious argument!

3. Poll is NOT Multiple Choice!

As much as I like Part V, Roy is just a cheap copycat, he would stand no chance against Jason. Probably give him a bit of a trouble, but Jason would emerge as an ultimate winner at the end!

We're talking Human vs. "Human" here.

Ivan1987 wrote:As much as I like Part V, Roy is just a cheap copycat, he would stand no chance against Jason. Probably give him a bit of a trouble, but Jason would emerge as an ultimate winner at the end!

We're talking Human vs. "Human" here.

I had an unpleasant debate about this on YouTube and the guy ignored all the facts, Ive posted to him and blocked me after the fact that he couldn't disprove any of my valid points.

Roy is a good killer, don't get me wrong but by feats alone from Strength and Durability? Jason is beating this man silly! It's like Brock Lesnar Vs Steven Seagal.

Man, I would never get involved in a YouTube discussion, to begin with.

Ivan1987 wrote:Man, I would never get involved in a YouTube discussion, to begin with.

Trust me! He tried to argue that the Tracer that hit Roy was full speed and that Roy did better display of "Strength", I couldn't stop laughing at his responses.

I'm thinking Jason. He survived drowning, hanging from a barn loft, a machete to the head, a knee injury and still keeps coming at you.

Roy wouldn't be as lucky.

ThePunisher wrote:I'm thinking Jason.  He survived drowning, hanging from a barn loft, a machete to the head, a knee injury and still keeps coming at you.  

Roy wouldn't be as lucky.  

I agree but some of these Roy fans be crazy with their arguments lol!

Jason Voorhees wrote:

ThePunisher wrote:I'm thinking Jason.  He survived drowning, hanging from a barn loft, a machete to the head, a knee injury and still keeps coming at you.  

Roy wouldn't be as lucky.  

I agree but some of these Roy fans be crazy with their arguments lol!

One of the things I've noticed about some horror fans is that they seem so...........

I guess what I'm saying is that we all love our horror, but some people are so wrapped up in it and take it a bit too seriously.

ThePunisher wrote:

Jason Voorhees wrote:

ThePunisher wrote:I'm thinking Jason.  He survived drowning, hanging from a barn loft, a machete to the head, a knee injury and still keeps coming at you.  

Roy wouldn't be as lucky.  

I agree but some of these Roy fans be crazy with their arguments lol!

One of the things I've noticed about some horror fans is that they seem so...........

I guess what I'm saying is that we all love our horror, but some people are so wrapped up in it and take it a bit too seriously.

I agree, people truly believe Roy was stronger than Jason? I'm sorry but in a single film Roy didn't show the same strength feats like Jason did across 3 prior films.

I watched a ridiculous video on this topic years ago that I barely remember it, but one of their arguments involved Roy bursting through a door as proof he had super strength like Jason... Rather than the more obvious explanation that the movie was just still trying to put doubt in your mind whether this was the real Jason or not... A bit pointless sine the blue mask was meant to be a giveaway that Roy was an imposter Jason, but still...

Roy being better than Jason is a really weird hill to die on... And this is from someone who enjoys Part 5.

I'm Not a Goalie wrote:I watched a ridiculous video on this topic years ago that I barely remember it, but one of their arguments involved Roy bursting through a door as proof he had super strength like Jason... Rather than the more obvious explanation that the movie was just still trying to put doubt in your mind whether this was the real Jason or not... A bit pointless sine the blue mask was meant to be a giveaway that Roy was an imposter Jason, but still...

Roy being better than Jason is a really weird hill to die on... And this is from someone who enjoys Part 5.

Like seriously lol! It's a Real weird hill like I can get it...

Part V was their 1st and they wanna hype Roy...but there's some reality here even from a perspective.

That Door scene? Roy used his "side" to break down the door, and then Part 4 Jason is out here using his PALMS to shatter a door, the strength difference in that alone tells me who's stronger.

The diehard Part V fans will claim so much for no reason the worse part of their "Arguments" of you trying to call it that is that "Roy had more kills than Jason did in a single film! So Roy is a better killer." But that doesn't make him the better killer lol! It's like Corey having more kills than Michael and then saying "Corey's better than Michael" like it makes no sense to make such claims and stick by it.

Jason Voorhees wrote:

I'm Not a Goalie wrote:I watched a ridiculous video on this topic years ago that I barely remember it, but one of their arguments involved Roy bursting through a door as proof he had super strength like Jason... Rather than the more obvious explanation that the movie was just still trying to put doubt in your mind whether this was the real Jason or not... A bit pointless sine the blue mask was meant to be a giveaway that Roy was an imposter Jason, but still...

Roy being better than Jason is a really weird hill to die on... And this is from someone who enjoys Part 5.

Like seriously lol! It's a Real weird hill like I can get it...

Part V was their 1st and they wanna hype Roy...but there's some reality here even from a perspective.

That Door scene? Roy used his "side" to break down the door, and then Part 4 Jason is out here using his PALMS to shatter a door, the strength difference in that alone tells me who's stronger.

The diehard Part V fans will claim so much for no reason the worse part of their "Arguments" of you trying to call it that is that "Roy had more kills than Jason did in a single film! So Roy is a better killer." But that doesn't make him the better killer lol! It's like Corey having more kills than Michael and then saying "Corey's better than Michael" like it makes no sense to make such claims and stick by it.

I'm sticking with Jason.